My children love a sprinkle of parmesan cheese on almost everything they eat, no matter if it’s an omelet, spinach tacos or veggie burgers.
However, adding cheese to their meals, risks me having to spend time cleaning sticky burnt particles from the pan. I eventually end up with a no-longer-nonstick pan that needs to be replaced.
The Blue Diamond pan adverts claim a superior and more durable non stick performance. If true it would solve many problems.
Yet does the pan perform as claimed? Read this Blue Diamond pan review to find out!
Spoiler Alert! If you can’t be bothered to read the review and just want to know whether to buy Blue Diamond: The Blue Diamond pan is OK and a good value pan to buy. Yet I would recommend the Michelangelo Pan instead. Read on to find out why.
Things to Consider Before Buying a Diamond Infused Nonstick Pan
Despite a wide range of nonstick pans raging in the market, it’s still hard to find a product that packs efficiency, safety and durability altogether.
Those pans with a high nonstick ability fail to serve you for more than a couple of months, and those that last longer are not 100 percent safe or nonstick.
A diamond-infused nonstick pan—such as the Blue Diamond pan— has the potential to address this. The diamond infused surface should allow it to be durable and avoid toxic ingredients
However, Blue Diamond doesn’t state clearly whether its products contain PTFE—the active ingredient of Teflon that some consumers look to avoid. I’ll cover this below, but while there are concerns over the ingredient, it is safe to cook with if you use it properly.
A big plus is that the cookware can, supposedly, resist the stickiest foods and last for years with proper maintenance.
If you’re a busy parent who wants to prepare quick healthy food for your family and avoid spending your time and money dealing with substandard cookware, a diamond-infused non-stick pan is convenient.
But before buying any cookware, you should make sure they are:
- A fair price.
- Easy to clean.
- Suitable for your stove.
- Able to conduct even heat.
- Safe and easy to use.
Presenting the Blue Diamond Pan
Blue Diamond is a renowned brand for nonstick utensils that manufacture individual stockpots, pans and entire cookware sets.
From saucepans and grill pans to griddles and skillets, Blue Diamond cookware comes in a wide variety of sizes and capacities. Yet, the focus of this Blue Diamond pan review is on the 10-inch frypan.
This pan comes with a blue design, ceramic interior, diamond dust finish, and metallic handles. With its standard 10-inch design, it allows you to cook two portions of meat or fry three eggs at once.
The first time I saw the blue diamond ad on TV, I asked myself, is Blue Diamond cookware any good for my daily cooking? And after all the research I’ve done, here are some of its positive and negative aspects:
- A more durable surface compared to similar products
- Quick and even heat distribution
- Absolutely nonstick
- Lightweight and stylish design
- Handles are not cool-touch
- Probably contains PTFE
- Doesn’t live up to claims like non-scratch surface
Blue Diamond Pan Review: Features and Benefits
Shape and Design
When it comes to decorative features, an image of a Blue Diamond cookware set speaks for itself. The pan is radiant blue on the outside and has a smooth ceramic coating inside.
It has an 8-inch, comfortable handle that facilitates gripping, rotating and tossing food.
The sides are not too short nor too long, which is ideal for cooking various recipes. The oil doesn’t run over the walls, and at the same time, you won’t burn your hands while using a spatula.
One disappointing thing about its design is that the handle can get hot when used on high heat, so you’ll need to use a mitt.
Cookware manufacturers use various coatings to produce non-stick products and different methods to spray or attach the coatings. So, based on the material they use, the amount and density of layers and the manufacturing method, nonstick pans may vary in terms of quality.
Blue Diamond uses a multilayer ceramic substrate that is infused with tough diamonds. Since diamonds are the hardest material for protecting other objects, Blue Diamond cookware should be less likely to warp, peel or degrade after a few months of usage.
Compared to many pans out there on the market, this one is alleged to be “10 times more durable” and should maintain its non-stick properties.
In reality, customers do report that this pan can get damaged just like other pans. It’s not invulnerable! Diamond infused isn’t the same as an actual diamond. (Wouldn’t that be great – a diamond pan you could never break or scratch? Sadly we’re not there yet.)
This pan might be less durable than others though. There are reports of it scratching easily, including on the inside. As soon as a non stick coating starts to peel I would throw it away. So there’s a good chance this pan won’t last long.
The manufacturer stated that the cookware is free from toxic substances such as PFAs, cadmium, and lead. This makes it sound like a healthy option for your cooking routine. Yet reputable cookware is free of these substances these days anyway.
However, the product description says nothing about Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) – the active ingredient in Teflon and most non-stick. After all I’ve heard about the toxicity concerns of PTFE ingredients, the first question that occurred to me was, “Is Blue Diamond ceramic cookware safe for my children?”
To answer that question, I emailed the manufacturer to see whether they include PTFE in their cookware, but I received no answer. So it seems likely that the pan contains PTFE.
Unless you use temperatures as high as 260°C (500°F)—which is unlikely in a kitchen—PTFE won’t release toxic gases.
This means if you adhere to some cautious tips, it’s not dangerous for your home setting. Besides, unlike PFOA, PTFE is FDA-approved and food-safe so that it shouldn’t cause any threats to your family.
Yet what I dislike is that many people are trying to avoid PTFE and could buy the pan without realizing what it includes.
In terms of safety, it has firm handles and is oven-safe. This pan can withstand up to 450°C (850°F), so you can use it in both a broiler and oven with no worries.
The handle can get hot when cooking which can be a safety factor.
If you ask me, I would say the best thing about Blue Diamond frying pan is its reasonable price.
Since I’m fond of quick skillet recipes, frying pans are the handiest tools around my kitchen. So, I’ve bought—and unfortunately, destroyed—several pans over the years.
If know any pan you are going to buy will get damaged anyway, Blue Diamond might be a good choice. It’s inexpensive to buy and cheap to replace.
Other than durability, the diamond-infused coating of this pan makes it a great conductor of heat.
The product description says it’s four times better in transferring the heat, and a 2018 technical report by CSA Group has approved the claim. Blue Diamond skillet reviews have given high ratings for its heat distribution and cooking speed.
The pan also has a ceramic nonstick finish that allows everything to slide out of the pan once cooked.
Some customers report the non-stick coat wears off after a couple of weeks. Yet other users that took good care of the pan faced no sticking issues even with frequent uses.
Another reason that makes the coating peel off after a while is that many websites—including the manufacturer—introduce it as metal-resistant, while it’s not. It’s best to avoid metal, as some users found you can scratch the surface of the pan and ruin the non-stick ability.
Yet again it feels like an OK pan for the price, but one that’s been “bigged up” beyond it’s actual capabiliies.
As nothing should stick to the pan, this makes the cooking and cleaning process easier. With the ceramic surface, Blue Diamond pans clean with a single wipe, so you won’t need much time, force, or effort to wash them.
Plus, I have even better news for comfort-seekers. All Blue Diamond pans are safe in the dishwasher!
Yet I wouldn’t recommend the dishwasher. Since it’s so easy to clean, just wash it quickly by hand. The non stick surface is less likely to wear away if you take care.
Compared to the heavy copper-blended pans on the market, this pan has a diamond-infused ceramic layer that makes it super lightweight and easy-to-carry. It weighs only about 1.75 pounds (0.8kg), so you can easily flip and serve food.
According to Blue Diamond cookware reviews, you can use this cookware on various types of stovetops such as ceramic, gas, halogen, and electric. Unfortunately, induction stovetops are not on that list.
This is fine with me because I have a typical gas stove. But if induction-friendly pans are your only choice, skip the product and go for its alternatives that I’ve mentioned below.
Alternatives to the Blue Diamond Pan
Similar to what you read in the Blue Diamond pan review, this product has blue exteriors, ceramic interiors and diamond-infused inner layers. According to customer feedback, the handles are comfortable for lifting and turning the food out, but they get hot because of the metallic design.
Overall, if you’re looking for a PTFE-free version of Blue Diamond frying pan, this 10-inch skillet is for you.
Here’s a short comparison between MICHELANGELO vs. Blue Diamond pan:
- Induction compatible, while Blue Diamond pan is not.
- Withstands about 232°C (450°F), which is almost half the heat resistance of a Blue Diamond, yet more than enough for most uses.
- Free from all Teflon ingredients—including PTFE.
- Includes a lid.
- Both are dishwasher- and oven-safe.
- Both are great conductors of heat.
This item costs three times more than the Blue Diamond but offers almost the same features. It has the same weight, the same size, and almost the same construction. But if you care about cool-touch handles and don’t mind paying a few bucks more, this might be a better match for you.
Here’s a short list of Swiss Diamond vs. Blue Diamond features:
- Has good non-stick properties but it may not last.
- Has a diamond-infused, aluminum design.
- Unlike Blue Diamond, it receives customer praise for its cool-touch handles.
- Both get high ratings for heat conductivity and ergonomic handles.
- More expensive.
- Swiss Diamond contains PTFE (Teflon active ingredient) as does, most likely, Blue Diamond.
Another alternative for the Blue Diamond pan is this Granite Stone frying pan that’s oven safe to 280°C (550°F). It has three thick aluminum layers that are reinforced by hard diamond, offering truly non-stick properties. If you need something large for your dinner parties, you might want to consider this option.
My concern is that it isn’t clear from the product description if it is PTFE free. (PTFE is the active ingredient of Teflon). When these things aren’t clear – that’s not a good sign, and I suspect it contains PTFE. Not the end of the world, but not great if you are trying to avoid it.
Here’s other features of Granite Stone in comparison to Blue Diamond:
- The size is almost twice the Blue Diamond.
- The handles are rather cool to the touch.
- Granite Stone handles have sharp ends and are not as comfortable as Blue Diamond handles.
- The pan is 1 pound heavier due to its larger capacity.
- It’s not as efficient in terms of heat distribution.
- Granite Stone is likely to contain PTFE (just like Blue Diamond).
If you’re looking for a quality, affordable, nonstick pan, for the price, Blue Diamond nonstick pans are OK. Whether you need an oven griddle pan, sautépan, or a covered frypan, Blue Diamond has you covered.
It’s not the greatest quality but the replacement cost is so low it could be worth a punt.
Yet I would hesitate to buy Blue Diamond. There’s two reasons:
- I don’t like how they talk about their diamond reinforced technology when underlying it is basically a version of Teflon. I think people might buy it to avoid PTFE or Teflon and be let down.
- My impression is that some other non stick pans are of higher quality – meaning they will last longer. Non stick will never last forever, but it’s always good to get as high quality as possible.
So, personally, I’d turn to the Michelangelo pan. It’s PTFE free and about as durable as nonstick gets. It’s also diamond-infused and offers the same attractive look as other pans in this sector.