The 8 Best Griddle Pans For Pancakes (Reviewed 2020)

In a rush and just want to know which griddle to buy?

My personal favorite pancake griddle is the Cooks Standard Hard Anodized Nonstick Square Griddle Pan

My children love nothing more than waking up to pancakes for breakfast. I prepare the mixture the day before, leave it in the fridge and start the day with pancakes!

I cook one pancake at a time and cut it in half so they each get something at the same time. If I’m lucky I can griddle myself a quick pancake before I need to do the next one for them!

The truth is that you can prepare pancakes in a frying pan or skillet. You don’t need anything special.

A decent pancake griddle pan can make the job easier though, and perhaps allow you to cook more than one pancake at the same time.

What To Look For In The Best Griddle Pan For Pancakes

In these guides I like to take you through what you should think about. This will help you find the best pancake griddle pan for you, not just my favorite.

Versatility

I don’t have enough room in my kitchen, or money to spend, to have a pan for every type of thing I cook. Size, shape and a nonstick surface are often the biggest versatility factors.

I’ll explain what else you can use these pancake griddles for.

Electric or Stovetop

An electric pancake griddle will do a lot of the work for you, it normally griddles both sides at once.

However, you can’t pop it in the dishwasher and it tends to take up more counter space. Counter space is more valuable than cupboard space for me. Worse, having a cluttered counter makes the kitchen look messy.

An electric pancake griddle could be great if you are doing pancakes every day. It’s there and ready to use. They are normally nonstick so you can likely just wipe the surface after you use it.

Which stove

Gas stoves tend to work with everything. This means that the best pancake griddle for your gas stove is likely just the best pancake griddle. For griddles, electric stoves also tend to work with everything.

If you are looking for a pancake griddle for an induction cooktop that’s a different kettle of fish. These need certain materials to work – I’ll highlight this for you.

Sometimes people ask – what is the best pancake griddle for glass top stoves? Glass top stoves are often induction stoves. You should check your own stove instructions though.

Height of Lip / Side

A skillet, or frying pan, has high sides and a sauté pan has even higher sides. This allows you to cook in them while containing mess (or even to cook sauces).

With a griddle there is either a small lip or no lip around the side. This makes it easier to get a large turner under whatever you are griddling. This is because you don’t have any lip or side to get in the way.

If the griddle is big enough, having a lip is not such a big deal. Of course, the other side of the coin is that having a high side gives you more versatility.

A pancake on a griddle with not lip at all.

I’ll highlight whether the pancake pans I review have a side or not. This lets you choose the best griddle pan for your pancakes!

Dash Mini Maker Electric Round Griddle

This is a cute little pancake griddle that is very versatile – if you are one person! It’s so easy to cook with but so tiny.

It’s great for a fried breakfast if you are happy to cook one, or two eggs at a time! (Perhaps you only want one egg?)

This round electric pancake griddle is not for me. I need something that can cook a bit more, is easier to clean up and doesn’t take up valuable counter space!

Pros:

  • Comes with recipe book
  • Versatile
  • Small footprint
  • Closed lid makes cleanup easier
  • Highly affordable. 

Cons:

  • Takes up countertop space
  • Electric = not for the dishwasher!
  • One smallish pancake or two eggs at a time
  • Some spatter even with lid down
  • Not easy to clean

Cooks Standard Nonstick Square Griddle Pan

This large square griddle pan is ideal for cooking two to four small pancakes at once. It is large enough to fit more than one pancake, while being small enough to fit on one burner.

What’s more the lip is a perfect size for a griddle. It’s low enough that it doesn’t get in the way of the turner, and high enough to contain any oil you use.

This pan is incredibly versatile. It’s fantastic for frying up eggs or breakfasts. You could sear a steak with it or warm up some bread.

The product page says “Dishwasher safe, hand wash recommended.” I’m not sure what that means – either you can stick it in the dishwasher or you can’t. The manufacturer should be clearer on this.

Yet … my experience with nonstick in general is that you can stick it in the dishwasher if you are careful. Make sure nothing metallic can touch the surface and don’t use a harsh detergent.

This griddle won’t last forever but it is a versatile pan that you should get good use from. It’s not cheap, but for what you get, it is a steal.

Pros:

  • Lip is perfect size for griddle
  • Nonstick – easy to clean up
  • In theory dishwasher safe
  • Solid handle that stays cool

Cons:

  • Not induction stove compatible
  • “Hand wash recommended”
  • Can lost nonstick properties over time

Presto Ceramic Electric Griddle

This is a big electric griddle. It does mean you can cook up breakfast for the whole family in one go. It’s super versatile in terms of what you can cook.

The slight lip is perfect for containing oil, while letting you get the turner under the food you are griddling.

Since it’s electric you don’t need to worry if your stove breaks, or you don’t have a stove. As long as you can plug it in, this will just work.

The problem is, it is very big. I can’t imagine storing this on my countertop, but I also don’t know where else I would put it. Also, this might not leave any food preparation space when you do have it on the countertop.

This electric pancake griddle is ideal for big kitchens and big families. It gives you extra cooking surface, in addition to your stove, and is super versatile.

It’s not for me, because my kitchen is too small, and I don’t think I need a griddle this big anyway.

In theory you can take it apart to store it and to put the cooking surfaces in the dishwasher. That’s not for me as I don’t like to dismantle and setup cookware each time I use it.

It’s not cheap but on a per square foot basis it’s quite reasonable!

Pros:

  • Slight lip – perfect for griddling
  • Versatile
  • Great for large families – lots of extra cooktop space
  • Ceramic nonstick surface – easy to clean up
  • Grease catcher to minimise mess and reduce fat

Cons:

  • It’s too big – you need a large kitchen
  • Uneven heating over the surface of the pan
  • If / when electric components fail it becomes useless

Lodge Cast Iron Griddle and Hot Handle Holder

So, first off, cast iron isn’t for everyone. Check out my guide to cooking with and caring for cast iron if you aren’t sure.

For some reason, at the time of writing, the product page claims this griddle is dishwasher safe. Forget about it. Cast iron is never dishwasher safe. Believe me I’m happy to stick things in the dishwasher, but not this griddle.

That said if you want a pancake griddle to pass on to your grandchildren, this could be the one for you.

It’s beautifully designed and high quality for a reasonable price.

Pros:

  • Cast Iron will last forever if treated right
  • Great quality Lodge pan
  • Nice handle cover
  • Induction compatible
  • Round shape ideal for pancakes
  • Lip on edge is perfect size

Cons:

  • Cast iron is extra work to look after
  • Cast iron is not dishwasher safe whatever the product page says
  • Perhaps a tad small – one large pancake at a time

Emoji Smiley Face Pancake Pan

This nonstick pancake griddle comes with 7 different faces. You cook the pancake in one of the built in molds and out it comes as a giant emoji.

In a way, this is great for cooking pancakes for the whole family (yourself included) at the same time.

It can be a bit tricky to flip the pancakes. I would suggest using another surface to help “catch” the pancakes when you turn them over.

The problem for me is that this is so limited in use – it’s the opposite of versatile!

All in all I would say a nice idea but not really very practical. Let’s be honest, it’s the sort of thing you use once or twice and then gets forgotten about at the back of the cupboard!

Pros:

  • Nice faces for kids – makes it more fun!
  • Induction compatible

Cons:

  • Only one of each face. You can bet your kids will all want the same face at the same time!
  • Much more limited what you can actually fry / griddle with this pan
  • Tricky to flip the pancakes – may need to dig them out and place on a regular griddle

Calphalon Square Griddle Pan

This is a lovely griddle pan for cooking all the family a small pancake each. The lip is the right height and the pan the right size and shape.

Since it is dishwasher safe and nonstick, clean up is cinch.

It is a little bit more expensive than other pans, and at this price you do kind of expect good quality. On the whole that’s what it has – you can feel its sturdiness when you pick it up.

Unfortunately there are reports of it warping.

If you think you can look after it, you do get a decent pan for your money.

Pros:

  • Nice size – cook 3-4 pancakes at once on a single burner
  • Nonstick for easy clean up
  • Lip is right height for a griddle
  • Solid cool to touch handle
  • Dishwasher safe

Cons:

  • Pricier end of the market
  • Doesn’t work on induction stoves
  • Warps if not treated right

Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Open Skillet

This 8 inch skillet isn’t a griddle per se. Its high sides mean that it is more of a frying pan. Still, it can serve as a round pancake griddle.

I often use my frying pan to griddle pancakes and with the right turner (i.e. one with a bit of flex) you should be fine.

That said this is a little bit small. You need to leave space to fit the turner in, so there’s only enough room for one medium size pancake at a time.

Since this is a stainless steel pancake pan (or frying pan) it is harder to clean. You also need to be more careful to stop food sticking. It definitely isn’t Teflon!

You could use this versatile little pan for cooking pancakes, frying, sauteing or even preparing sauces.

A nice pan for a single person, perhaps for a young adult leaving home for the first time. It’s too small for me though.

Pros:

  • Dishwasher safe
  • Very efficient heating – take care until you are used to it
  • Cool touch solid handle
  • Good price for the quality

Cons:

  • Bottom discolors / stains and it’s hard to get out
  • Not true nonstick – need to prewarm first and use lots of oil
  • Handle can get hot if cooking for a long time
  • Difficult to clean
  • No lid – would have increased versatility of skillet
  • Not induction compatible

Calphalon Stainless Steel Saute Pan with Cover

Is this a round pancake griddle or a sauté pan? Obviously it’s really a sauté pan. So why did I include it?

The thing is you can use pans like this to griddle pancakes, what’s more they are more versatile than a griddle. You can cook a family breakfast with this pan, prepare a sauce or sear a steak

Unfortunately there is a slight bow in the base. This isn’t ideal as liquids will flow outwards. In this case, if you have got your pancake mix thick enough, it will help you spread the pancake. If your pancake mixture is too thin, your pancake will have a hole in the middle.

The price means it is definitely a premium product. And you can see why – it is sturdy, has lots of uses and should last a long time. 

There are reports of it occasionally warping slightly. This isn’t the end of the world but unacceptable at this price range.

Pros:

  • Can use on induction stoves
  • Extra handle in case it is fully laden
  • Nice size big enough for a large pancake
  • Good heat distribution
  • Quality product
  • Extremely versatile
  • See through lid

Cons:

  • Very expensive
  • Slight bow upwards in base can leave inside dry
  • Very heavy
  • Prone to slight warping after use – unacceptable at this price

Verdict

Best Pancake Griddle (Overall)

My personal favorite pancake griddle is the Cooks Standard Hard Anodized Nonstick Square Griddle Pan. It’s a true griddle pan. It’s nonstick which means easy cleanup.

In theory it’s dishwasher safe but you might want to be careful at first since the product page caveats this. Personally I would stick it in the dishwasher but it’s a risk.

Although suitable for induction stoves this is also the best pancake griddle for gas stoves. It’s large surface would work well with the flames of a gas stove.

The clincher for me is that it is the perfect size to cook 4 small pancakes so that the whole family is happy.

Sure it’s not the cheapest, but nor is it the most expensive and for something that will last and be used, I think it’s worth it.

Best Stainless Steel Pancake Griddle

Perhaps this should be the best pancake skillet, because the Calphalon Stainless Steel Sauté Pan with Cover isn’t a true griddle. But that can be an advantage! You can do more with a skillet as the sides are higher. It’s fine as long as you have a flexible (silicone) turner and a little dexterity. You just bend the turner under the pancake.

I love this pan and I know it will last. It’s the most versatile of all the pans I’ve reviewed here (hence why I made up a category for it!)

If I have one doubt it’s that stainless steel is a bit more work than nonstick.

Check Price on Amazon

Share this post

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email
Share on print