The holidays aren’t complete without holiday cookies and other baked goods. While many people are trying alternatives to harmful ingredients like sugar and highly processed grains, it’s easy to overlook another consideration: the bakeware.
When it comes time to pop those treats in the oven, you want a baking sheet that’s safe to use.
Having non-toxic bakeware is essential for getting the most out of your baking.
I like the Wildone Stainless Steel Sheet Pan & Cooling Rack set because its stainless steel construction is non-toxic, durable, scratch-resistant, and easy to clean.
But you might want a different material for your non-toxic bakeware. Perhaps you prefer a non-stick surface or something dishwasher-safe. Whatever your preferences, there are non-toxic baking pans that can fit your baking needs.
Which non-toxic baking sheet is best for you? Let’s dive in.
At a Glance
Wildone Stainless Steel Baking Sheet & Rack Set: Best Overall Non-Toxic Baking Sheet
This Wildone Stainless Steel Baking Set includes two baking pans and two cooling racks. While this particular pan measures 16×12 inches (41×30 cm), there are multiple sizes available.
The metal pans and cooling racks are designed to work together or separately, depending on your cooking needs.
All four pieces are made of high-quality, uncoated 18/0 stainless steel. That means these pans are durable, dishwasher-safe, and free of toxic chemicals.
The superior mirror stainless steel finish looks nice and helps reduce food sticking, but don’t expect the pans to remain spotless. The 18/0 means there is no nickel content, which is typically added to prevent stains.
The smooth edges and thick rod of the racks make these stainless steel pans easy to store.
Customers were pleased with the performance of this stainless steel baking sheet. They liked the size of the sheet pans and the fact that they’re free of any toxic chemical coating.
There were some reports of warping at various temperatures, as low as 375°F (190°C), but most said the pans went back fairly quickly. Still, I might avoid super high temperatures to be on the safe side.
The Wildone stainless steel baking sheet is great for making cookies, cinnamon rolls, cornbread, and more.
- Multiple sizes available
- 100% non-toxic
- Dishwasher-safe, easy to clean
- Stain easily
- Reports of warping
GreenLife Bakeware Ceramic Nonstick 18″ x 13″ Half Cookie Sheet Baking Pan: Best Ceramic Baking Sheet
GreenLife is one of the leaders in non-toxic cookware. The company brings the same colorful flair and health-conscious materials to its bakeware. This GreenLife Baking Pan is 18×13 inches (46×33 cm), large enough to fit 12-20 cookies, depending on the size.
The aluminum cookie sheet is coated to make it non-stick. GreenLife uses Thermolon, a healthy ceramic coating that’s free of PFOA, PFAS, PTFE, lead, and cadmium.
This baking pan is great for baking cookies and roasting vegetables. This GreenLife baking sheet is oven-safe up to 450°F (230°C). It’s not broiler-safe, but it should handle most everyday baking tasks.
Cleanup is simple. Wipe clean with mild dish soap and a non-abrasive sponge. The ceramic coating has excellent food release, so it’s not difficult to clean. But this baking pan is not dishwasher-safe.
To get the most out of your GreenLife ceramic bakeware, avoid using metal utensils. Customer reviews complained of scratching, so treat this baking pan with extra caution.
GreenLife also recommends using oil or butter but avoiding cooking sprays. Sprays can break down the coating. Finally, be sure to let the pan cool down completely before washing. Extreme temperature changes can warp aluminum baking sheets.
If you’re in the market for an affordable, colorful, non-stick baking sheet, this GreenLife pan is a great pick. You’ll have to baby it to avoid scratching, but it still brings a lot of value to the kitchen.
- Bright color options
- Teflon-free and non-toxic
- Thermolon non-stick coating
- Oven-safe up to 450°F (230°C)
- Generous size
- Hand wash only
- Scratches easily
All-Clad Stainless Steel Baking Sheet: Best Splurge Baking Sheet
All-Clad is practically synonymous with stainless steel cookware, but the U.S.-based company also manufactures stainless steel bakeware. This All-Clad Stainless Steel Baking Sheet measures 14×17 inches (36 x 43 cm), with plenty of surface area for baked goods.
This is the only piece on my list that features a tri-ply construction. This baking sheet is made from three bonded layers of metal, with an aluminum core and a stainless steel exterior.
The aluminum is great for heat distribution and heat responsiveness, while the stainless steel is non-toxic, non-reactive, and possesses excellent heat retention.
One unique feature is the angled edge, which makes it easy to take the pan in and out of the oven. It can also handle oven temperatures up to 600°F (315°C) without warping, so it’s great for roasted vegetables as well as baked goods.
Buyers gave rave reviews to the All-Clad baking pan. They loved the durability, performance, and ability to handle high heat. There were a couple of isolated complaints of warping, both at extremely high temperatures. Overall, though, customers loved this pan.
The biggest drawback is the cost. As with most All-Clad products, this baking pan is quite expensive. It’s a splurge pick, but the excellent quality might just make this pan worth it to you.
- Tri-ply construction, durable
- Angled edge for easy transfer
- Even heat distribution
- Oven-safe to 600°F (315°C)
- Made in the U.S.A.
CopperKitchen 3-Piece Baking Set: Best Ceramic Bakeware Set
CopperKitchen is one of several brands that manufactures copper-colored non-stick bakeware and cookware. This CopperKitchen 3-Piece Baking Set includes two 16×12-inch baking pans (42×31 cm) and a 13×9 (33×23 cm) roasting pan.
It’s important to note that the baking pans do not contain any copper. They are simply copper-colored. Instead, the pans have a non-stick ceramic coating that’s non-toxic and free of PFOA, PFAS, & PTFE (i.e., Teflon).
These CopperKitchen pans are oven-safe up to 500°F (260°C), which makes them suitable for a variety of dishes.
They’re also easy to clean. Simple wash with mild dish soap and warm water, using a non-abrasive sponge or dishcloth.
CopperKitchen claims these pans are dishwasher-safe, but some customers said their pans didn’t hold up well in the dishwasher. I recommend hand washing to be safe.
Buyers liked the lightweight nature of this non-stick bakeware, as well as the excellent food release. because the pans are lighter than other non-toxic bakeware picks, they might not stand up to as much use over time.
The biggest drawback I see is that copperKitchen is not very forthcoming about the interior material. It’s clearly metal, but it’s difficult to know which type. It could be aluminized steel, but based on the lighter weight, I’d say it’s plain aluminum.
However, they’re very affordable, so you won’t have to break the bank to enjoy non-stick cookware that isn’t toxic.
- Non-stick ceramic pans
- Non-toxic coating
- Oven-safe up to 500°F (260°C)
- Dishwasher-safe (hand washing is better)
- Lightweight, easy to carry
- Unclear on interior metal
- Lacks long term durability
GreenLife Muffin Tin: Best Non-Toxic Muffin Tin
Just like GreenLife’s non-toxic sheet pans, this GreenLife Non-Toxic Muffin Tin is made for those who want healthy bakeware with a flair.
GreenLife offers muffin tins in a variety of cheery colors, from turquoise and navy to lavender and pink. It has 12 baking cups for muffins, cupcakes, and more.
Each tin has a proprietary Thermolon ceramic non-stick coating derived from sand and free of toxic chemicals.
This ceramic coating is non-stick and easy to clean. The body consists of 100% recycled aluminum for fast, even heating. You can put your GreenLife muffin pan in the oven up to 400°F (200°C) without worrying about warping.
While the muffin tin is not dishwasher-safe, the superior food release makes hand washing this pan a simple task. Of course, you can always use paper baking cups to make cleanup even easier.
It’s very important to avoid using metal forks or other metal utensils to remove food from the muffin cups. Buyers confirmed that these pans scratch easily, so you’ll want to treat them with kid gloves.
That being said, buyers were pleased with the non-stick performance of the GreenLife muffin tin. They also enjoyed the colorful exterior, although some had problems with chipping.
This tin is very affordable and a great pick for those who want non-toxic bakeware for muffins, egg cups, cupcakes, or other similar food.
- Four bright color choices
- Non-toxic, ceramic non-stick coating
- Made from recycled aluminum
- Oven-safe to 400°F (200°C)
- Easy to clean
- Hand wash only
- Scratches easily
Katbite Silicone Baking Mat Set: Best Silicone Mat Set
If you’re looking for liners to use with your non-stick baking sheets, these Katbite Silicone Mats are for you. This multi-purpose set includes three silicone baking mats.
Two are half-sheet size at 11.6×16.5 inches (30×42 cm), while the other is a quarter-sheet size at 11.5×8.5 inches (29×22 cm).
Silicone baking mats are great because they let the food heat and brown evenly, without retaining any odors.
Each silicone mat is made of WACKER food-grade silicone and premium fiberglass, which is non-toxic, BPA-free, and odorless. These mats will never tarnish or fade, making them a must-have kitchen accessory.
Typically, when I think of silicone mats, the words flimsy, thin, and cheap come to mind. However, these silicone mats are 0.7 mm thick, almost twice that of other mats (0.3 mm).
These thicker mats won’t slip or wrinkled when used, and they’ll hold up better over time.
One of the biggest advantages of silicone baking mats is that they’re non-stick and easy to clean. Simply wash them with warm soapy water. You can also put these mats in the dishwasher for extra convenience.
The mats are stain resistant, so they can look nice for a long time to come. They withstand temperatures from -40°F to 500°F (-40°C to 260°C). They’re thermal shock resistant and safe for oven use, the microwave, and the dishwasher.
Buyers were happy with their silicone mats. They found them convenient and great for non-stick baking. Several did report stains, however. This doesn’t affect the cooking performance, but you should be prepared for them to have brown spots after a while.
- Safe for oven temps up to 500°F (260°C)
- Thick, durable, flexible
- Non-stick and odor-resistant
- Microwave and dishwasher safe
- Easy to store, lightweight
- Reports of staining
Pyrex Glass Baking Dish: Best Glass Bakeware
When it comes to glass bakeware, Pyrex is a household name. This Pyrex 4-Piece Baking Dish Set includes a 3-quart (2.84 liters) baking dish, a 2-quart (1.89 liters) baking dish, and two plastic lids.
These baking dishes are perfect for helping you prepare, bake, and store your food with safety and ease. With a nesting design, these dishes fit inside one another and also other Pyrex dishes.
The Pyrex bakeware set has wide handles that give you a firm grip to avoid slips and spills. Plus, it’s easy to serve right out of the dish. It’s no wonder Pyrex is a staple of potlucks and gatherings. I’ve also made a specific review for Pyrex.
The high-quality, non-porous glass gives you peace of mind when storing your food. The tempered glass resists stains, flavors, and odors. It’s also dishwasher-safe, microwave-safe, freezer-safe, and preheated oven-safe.
What’s even better? The non-toxic lid is made of BPA-free plastic and is safe for the microwave, freezer, and the top rack of the dishwasher. The lids are designed to securely keep food fresh and tasty for a longer period of time.
When baking with Pyrex, it’s important to never take a pan from the oven to the freezer. Tempered glass has more strength than regular glass, but it’s not immune to thermal shock.
If you want to bake leftovers, be sure to leave them out for 30 minutes (or bring them to room temperature) before baking in a preheated oven.
Customers had glowing reviews of the Pyrex baking dish set. They loved the integrated handles and the ease of use and cleaning.
However, several buyers received cracked lids with their set. The good news is that this baking dish set has a limited 2-year warranty to replace broken items.
- Safe for oven, dishwasher, & microwave
- Tight-fitting BPA-free plastic lids
- Transparent for easy monitoring
- Non-toxic tempered glass construction
- Durable, sturdy
- Versatile; great for potlucks
- Reports of cracked lids
Le Creuset Stoneware Loaf Pan: Best Non-Toxic Loaf Pan
Le Creuset is the premier brand for enameled cast iron cookware. This Le Creuset loaf pan is perfect for making homemade bread and other baked goodies.
The cast iron body is covered with a porcelain enamel coating that’s naturally non-stick and nonporous, non-reactive, and scratch-resistant.
As always, Le Creuset offers loaf pans in a variety of bold color choices. The exterior colors are bright, while the interior sand-colored enamel resists stains and flavor absorption.
This loaf pan has excellent heat distribution for uniform browning and baking with no hot or cold spots. It also has superior heat retention to keep your bread tasting warm and fresh.
The Le Creuset loaf pan has easy food release for quick clean-up. It’s even dishwasher-safe, although hand washing is recommended.
When it comes to oven use, you can put this loaf pan in up to 500°F (260°C), making it great for a wide range of dishes.
Even though Le Creuset advertises these pans as safe for metal utensils, I recommend against it. Metal can scratch even the best porcelain enamel, so it’s best to stick to wooden or plastic cooking tools.
Buyers were quite happy with the Le Creuset loaf pan. They liked the size, the depth of the pan, and the easy cleaning.
Like all Le Creuset products, this one is a little pricey. But it’s a lot more affordable than other Le Creuset offerings, making it an attractive choice for those who want non-toxic bakeware.
- Beautiful porcelain enamel finish
- Durable cast iron interior
- Non-stick and stain-resistant
- Dishwasher-safe (hand washing recommended)
- Max oven temp of 500°F (260°C)
Le Creuset Stoneware Tart Dish: Best Stoneware Option
If quiche and tarts are your thing, you might enjoy this Le Creuset Stoneware Tart Dish.
Whereas most Le Creuset products are made from enameled cast iron, this baking dish features a stoneware construction with an exterior enamel. It’s available in three beautiful colors: Marseille blue, cerise, and white.
Stoneware is a great choice because it maintains even temperatures and prevents scorching. It’s also safe for the freezer, microwave, oven, broiler, and dishwasher.
However, you should never take a hot tart dish from the oven to the freezer. Let it cool completely before putting it in the fridge or freezer.
When removing it from the fridge, let it rest and come to room temp (or close) before baking in the oven.
This tart dish is non-absorbent so it won’t hold moisture or odors. The exterior enamel resists scratches and stains and is safe for cutting on with knives, not that I’d try it.
The nearly non-stick interior releases food for easy cleanup too.
Customers loved this Le Creuset tart dish. They enjoyed the easy food release and the ability to withstand higher temperatures.
This dish is pricey, which is unsurprising for Le Creuset. But it has excellent reviews and performance. I would readily recommend this for the pie baker.
- Even heating
- Handles high temps well
- Nearly non-stick interior
- Safe for oven & microwave
Non-Toxic Baking Pans: What You Need to Know
Why Should You Use Non-Toxic Bakeware?
It may surprise you to know that much of the bakeware on the market is manufactured with potentially harmful chemicals. These chemicals can leach into your food and possibly even cause negative health effects.
Lead and cadmium are used in baking sheets on a semi-frequent basis. These pans are also coated with chemicals to make them non-stick.
These toxic chemicals can leach into food, especially at higher temperatures. Using non-toxic baking sheets is important in protecting yourself from toxins.
What Makes a Non-Toxic Cookie Sheet?
The toxicity of baking sheets comes from the materials used to make and coat the pan.
Baking sheets are primarily made of metal, like stainless steel or aluminum. These metals are not harmful in themselves, although aluminum does react with acidic foods.
However, many pans have a non-stick coating for easy cleaning. This coating can scratch off if you use metal utensils and eventually end up in your food.
You could potentially be ingesting the toxic chemicals in the non-stick coating. That’s why it’s super important to toss any non-stick bakeware that has scratches or chips.
Some companies manufacture glass or ceramic baking sheets that are uncoated and non-toxic. These are your safest bet.
Are Aluminum Baking Sheets Safe?
In general, aluminum bakeware is safe to use. However, it’s best to take a few precautions.
You should use silicone-covered utensils when turning or stirring food and soft, non-abrasive sponges when cleaning the cookie sheet. Aluminum is a softer metal and scratches easily, so it’s important to avoid metal cooking tools.
Additionally, aluminum can leach into food in small amounts. This is especially true when cooking acidic foods. There is a correlation between ingesting aluminum and various health concerns.
While the thought of ingesting aluminum may sound scary, the reality is that the small amount that could pass into food is quite small and likely not a problem for healthy adults. It can be riskier for people with a history of renal failure or for small children.
If you want the absolute safest bakeware materials, I would go with stainless steel, cast iron, and ceramic bakeware. But aluminum baking sheets should be just fine with the proper care.
Is Aluminum Foil Safe?
If you’re like me, baking sheet liners are a convenient way to save time cleaning.
Aluminum foil is one of the most commonly used liners, but research suggests that high usage of aluminum foil can lead to negative health effects because it leaches into food when heated.
Parchment paper is another popular choice, especially for foods that bake at 350°F (180°C). Parchment paper is fine as long as it’s unbleached.
Bleached parchment paper may leach dioxins when heated. Dioxin is a by-product of the bleaching solution and can stay in the human body for up to 7 years.
The minuscule amount leached won’t do any immediate harm, but those looking to eliminate harmful chemicals from their baking should opt for unbleached parchment paper for extra precaution.
What Types of Non-Toxic Baking Sheets Are There?
Non-toxic baking sheets come in a variety of styles, sizes, and materials. But the material is the most important element in the safety of your bakeware. The safest bakeware materials are stainless steel, stone, ceramic, glass, and silicone.
Stainless Steel Baking Sheets
Stainless steel is a great material for baking because it’s durable, rust-resistant, heats evenly, and can handle higher temperatures. It’s not non-stick, so make sure you use cooking spray or oil on them before baking.
Many times, manufacturers add nickel to stainless steel to prevent rusting. The amount of chromium and nickel in a stainless steel alloy is listed as a percentage number. For instance, “18/10 stainless steel” has 18% chromium and 10% nickel.
If you let highly acidic or salty foods sit for a long time, it might release small amounts of nickel. You can avoid this by removing food from the pan (versus letting it sit for hours) or by buying nickel-free stainless steel cookie sheets (18/0 stainless).
The non-toxic stainless steel baking sheets I’ve recommended consist of either 18/10 or 18/0 stainless. That means you can bake without worry.
Ceramic Baking Sheets
Another non-toxic baking sheet option is ceramic. Ceramic baking sheets are naturally non-stick, durable, stain-resistant, and easy to clean.
If you’re set on having non-stick baking sheets, ceramic is your best option. You won’t find all the non-stick chemicals that have developed a bad reputation for harmful health effects.
A nice bonus? Ceramic can usually tolerate high heat, which means you’ll be able to bake at higher temperatures. Ceramic is also non-reactive, so it’s ideal for baking acidic foods.
In spite of ceramic’s advantages, many cookware companies aren’t forthcoming about the other ingredients they include in their non-stick coating. Some ceramic coatings still contain Teflon.
I recommend using caution. Check the product description and the manufacturer website for materials and care instructions.
Stoneware Baking Sheets
Stoneware is perfect for crisping foods in the oven. It has superb heat retention and doesn’t retain odors. Plus, it looks great and easily doubles as serving ware.
Stoneware baking pans come in two categories: unglazed and glazed. Unglazed stoneware is non-toxic, but it’s also porous and can absorb moisture. Glazed stoneware resists sticking and is easier to clean, but you have to be careful about the contents of the glaze.
I recommend unglazed stoneware over glazed, when you can find it. It’s a great choice for non-toxic bakeware. Just remember you can’t use soap or detergent on it. Instead, you should clean it with baking soda and water.
Glass is another option for non-toxic baking. Glass won’t warp in the dishwasher, and its transparency makes it easy to monitor food for doneness while cooking.
That being said, glass cooks a bit faster than metal, so you’ll have to adjust your cooking times if you choose to use glass bakeware.
Glass bakeware is also easy to clean. You can simply hand wash them in soapy water or most can be put in the dishwasher. To help release food, simply spray the baking pan with cooking oil or spray before using.
Most of the time, glass baking sheets are tempered to make them more durable and able to withstand higher temperatures.
They’re freezer-safe, too, but you should always let a dish cool to room temperature before putting it in the freezer. Thermal shock can happen, even to tempered glass. You don’t want to break your dish!
For recommendations on glass cookware for the stovetop, read my article on the best glass cookware. Also check out my article on baking with and freezing Pyrex.
Silicone Baking Mats
Another great option for non-toxic baking is silicone. Silicone baking mats consist of silica and can be used for a variety of recipes and dishes. Silicon can handle high heat and is naturally non-stick.
Silicone mats are easy to clean, and some are even dishwasher-safe.
However, silicone does have its limitations. It can melt if exposed to extreme heat for long periods of time. I would avoid using the broiler with a silicone baking mat.
Silicone mats are especially popular for muffin tins, loaf pans, and cupcake liners. These baked goods all benefit from a non-stick surface, and their required cooking temperature is low enough to avoid any melting concerns.
If you’re having a tough time deciding between these materials, consult the chart below for a quick reference guide:
|stainless steel||heavy-duty||rust-resistant||easy to clean|
|ceramic||withstands high heat||non-reactive||non-stick|
|stoneware||great for crisping||withstands high temperatures|
|glass||non-porous||easy to clean||no coating|
|silicone||easy to clean||non-stick||inexpensive|
Best Non-Toxic Baking Sheet: Final Thoughts
If you’re looking for the best non-toxic bakeware, I recommend the Wildone Stainless Steel Baking Sheet & Cooling Rack Set. It has the perfect blend of durability, utility, and value.
If you want something other than cookie sheets, I’d recommend the Pyrex 4-Piece Baking Set. I use my Pyrex on a daily basis, and it’s a great non-toxic, highly-utilitarian option.